The basic idea of “Columbo” is deceptively simple: there has been a murder and the dogged and friendly Lt. Columbo of the Los Angeles Police Department is on the case, always solving the case right at the end of the episode. The twist is how almost every episode unfolds, because the audience finds out who the killer is before Columbo has even shown up. Most episodes of “Columbo” are about 75 minutes long, and the first 15 or so of those minutes are dedicated to us learning the situation and understanding why someone would commit murder before they do the dirty deed. In essence, the suspense of each episode is in wondering how Columbo will capture his quarry, which is why the show belongs not to the “whodunit” sub-genre of mysteries but the ‘howcatchem” instead. 

Another quirk of the history of “Columbo” is that the first two episodes are considered separate one-off TV-movies, basically two separate pilot episodes, one of which aired in 1968 and the other aired in the spring of 1971. But when Steven Spielberg stepped behind the camera at the grand old age of 24, he was directing what would serve as the first regular episode of “Columbo,” entitled “Murder By the Book.” Though the show was created by Richard Levinson and William Link, “Murder by the Book” was written by Steven Bochco. If that name rings a bell, it should; Bochco would go on to write for or create shows like “L.A. Law,” “NYPD Blue” and “Hill Street Blues.” So, in essence, “Murder by the Book” was capturing lightning in a bottle without even realizing it. While no one would say (without being a loud contrarian) that “Murder by the Book” goes down as the greatest thing either of these Stevens made, it’s very easy to watch the episode and see the seeds of greatness, especially in Spielberg’s directing.

The plot of “Murder by the Book” revolves around a pair of authors, Ken Franklin and Jim Ferris (portrayed by Jack Cassidy and Martin Milner, respectively). They’ve been successfully co-writing a series of Miss Marple-esque detective novels for years, but Jim is ready to work on his own projects without Ken. Ken is dismayed by this primarily because he’s enjoyed a certain kind of lifestyle afforded by the success of the books … which he really hasn’t written much of for a very long time. So, to walk away with a handsome insurance policy, he lures Jim out to a quiet cabin of his where he kills his partner and tries to frame it on some unseen gangsters, implying that Jim was doing research for a book that the criminals wanted unpublished. Of course, things like this aren’t easy. Ken soon has to kill a local store owner who a) has a big crush on him and b) realizes that Ken killed his co-writer and wants to blackmail him for the privilege of being his lover.

The basic elements of almost every episode of “Columbo” is present in “Murder by the Book,” and the way it’s presented visually feels both Spielbergian and an effective template for how the show would look in future episodes and seasons. One of the critical but often unsung aspects of “Columbo” is that pretty much every episode serves as a commentary on class in the 1970s. Columbo himself, played so masterfully by Peter Falk, is the living embodiment of the word “rumpled,” with a raincoat that looks as if it’s been run over a few times, a ruffled haircut, and a seeming inability to remember what he placed in which pocket of his. (Falk’s amazing performance is all the more remarkable when you realize he wasn’t even the first choice to play the character.) Conversely, his suspects are among the toniest members of Los Angeles society. Here, it’s an upscale author, but future episodes would feature Columbo facing off against an NFL-style general manager, a world-renowned orchestral conductor (played by Falk’s longtime friend John Cassavetes), and the deputy chief of police, among others. Along with that, the look and feel of the episodes, the building tension between suspect and captor, and the epic, grand scale of how Columbo is presented against the backdrop of Los Angeles, all stems from how Spielberg so confidently utilizes these pieces in this first episode.